Others say that MapleShade should be in StarClan, do you agree?

Well, to be honest, she did break the warrior code by being mates with AppleDusk, but she thought it was the will of StarClan, so not too helpful for a start.
Now let's look at some other villains who got into StarClan! AshFur broke the code by giving assistance in one of Firestar's deaths, and he also tried to commit 4 other murders(SquirrelFlight, LionBlaze, JayFeather, and HollyLeaf) but horribly failed and led to his demise. But he still got into StarClan.
MudClaw tried to kill OneStar so that he could be clan leader because he thought that was what StarClan wanted, but he still whent to StarClan!
So that means that MapleShade should have gone to StarClan, too.

Translate

See all 0 comments