It’s hard “for me” to like Mapleshade. Because, she killed TO many innocent cats. Though Appledusk isn’t innocent in my book, I like him more than Mapleshade. Simply because a joke I made about Appledusk eating apples at dusk. And I don’t really have a joke for Mapleshade. Firestar will ALWAYS be my FAVORITE warrior cat. My favorite Warrior cat OC is Waterstar. Because I made him. And if it isn’t an OC I made then it’s Firestar’s OC Creamstar.